For God sake it isn’t anti-semitism

I had close friends round for dinner yesterday. We had just eaten. Relaxing on the sofa. Sipping our drinks/soft drinks. We had fully discussed homosexuality, Islam, Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, marriages between cousins, foreign policies, criminality. When I thought we had exhausted ourselves on topics to discuss we end up with Israel-Palestine on the agenda.

Everyone agreed with the plight of the Palestinian people, but few were willing to acknowledge the role played by former and present Israeli governments and Western foreign policies perpetuating the suffering of an oppressed people. Why was this I wondered.

It wasn’t until we brought the electing of Hamas in the Palestinian elections, that I realised that people were equating that with Palestinians being  indirectly responsible for the suicide bombings in Israel. “Killing scores of civilians to just kill 3 Israeli soldiers is not helping the situation (…) Palestinians have to show their willingness to cooperate (…) they should have accepted the Oslo accord” said my close friend.

“Mmmm… so imagine someone invades your home. Oppresses you. Makes your children suffer. Jails and tortures the men and boys in the house. Who should we ask to be reasonable, cooperative?  The oppressed or the oppressors?” I replied.

In any hostage situation it is of utmost importance to prevent loss of innocent life. Palestinians they are not seen as hostages in their own country. They are not seen as innocent civilians, but a people who are unwilling to accept the state of Israel and using violent means to resist. The question then arises: is it not human to feel bitterness, anger at a government which has systematically displaced you, uprooted your livelihood, used blockades to starve you, humiliate you at check points, killed someone you know through air attacks and bulldozed your home?

The psychology, the trauma of the Palestinians and their reasons for electing Hamas in the previous elections goes hand in hand. Unfortunately only Hamas has been able to understand the suffering of the Palestinian. They have opened schools, medical centers and activity centers for children. Of course they have also recruited suicide bombers and young men who are exasperated by their situation. Is it not easier to blow oneself up than to continue the suffering they are probably thinking. They are worth more dead than alive since they are unable to provide for their families except as human bombs – Hamas offers a monthly income to each family whose son sacrifices his life for the Palestinian cause.

We are not talking about people living safely tucked under their Ikea bedsheets tapping away on their keyboards or having the freedom to come and go without persecution, who have elected in a radical organisation. We are talking about generations of traumatised individuals. Yes  yes the Israelis were also once victims, but thank God there will never again be the slaughter of Jews in the world.


Because Israel receives several billions in aid from the US and their powerful Friends of Israel, not to mention the few hundred nukes Israel possess to threaten it’s neighbors and secure it’s position.

Is this anti-semitism someone asked. “For God sake it isn’t anti-semitism to criticise Israels role in the suppression, oppression and ethnic cleansing of a people. It is a issue of human rights – reducing criticism of Israel to anti-semitism is preventing a debate and an eventual boycott”.


~ by no2wars on 22/12/2008.

2 Responses to “For God sake it isn’t anti-semitism”

  1. Nice blog, and quite a breath of fresh air considering most of the ranting that passes as a political blog on WordPress these days!

    You’re right though, and I’m sick of people screaming anti-semitism when the Israeli gov is criticised, although I guess it’s a natural defence mechanism considering the countless atrocities that nations governments (voted in by the people) over the years have committed. What is even more frustrating about the apartheid in that part of the world is the fact that if they wanted to, the US could put so much economic pressure on the Israeli’s (ie, by not funding their military and economic expansion), they’d have to cut a deal with the Palestinians. Such a deal would not end up being one they’d like as it is the Israeli governments intention to gain as much as possible from Palestinian land and resources (what little there is of such) for her own use… most notably, access to water resources in Palestinian territory, leaving Palestinians to use water tankers.

    Nice blog, I’ll make sure I check it out again!

  2. Hi Kennedy,
    I totally agree with you. Do you remember Obama’s speech to the Jewish lobby? His words

    “I bring here an unshakeable commitment to Israel’s security (…) Israel’s security is sacrosanct. It is non-negotiable. The Palestinians need a state that is contiguous and cohesive, and that allows them to prosper – but any agreement with the Palestinian people must preserve Israel’s identity as a Jewish state, with secure, recognized and defensible borders. Jerusalem will remain the capital of Israel, and it must remain undivided (….) Just look at what Israel has accomplished in 60 years. From decades of struggle and the terrible wake of the Holocaust, a nation was forged to provide a home for Jews from all corners of the world – from Syria to Ethiopia to the Soviet Union. In the face of constant threats, Israel has triumphed. In the face of constant peril, Israel has prospered. In a state of constant insecurity, Israel has maintained a vibrant and open discourse, and a resilient commitment to the rule of law.

    When he committed himself to offering Israel a further $30 billion dollars of taxpayers money over the next 10 years I realised that the Palestinians were doomed and so was peace in the whole region.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: